What 25 Years in Business Consulting Taught Me About
The most valuable lessons in advisory work don't come from the wins. They come from the moments that don't go according to plan.
I want to be honest about something that doesn't come up often enough in thought leadership circles: I have been wrong. More times than I'd like. About markets, about people, about timing, about which variables mattered most.
Twenty-five years into this work, I've stopped being embarrassed about that. Failure — properly examined — is the most reliable source of durable wisdom I've found in business.
CONVICTION IS A TOOL. STUBBORNNESS IS A TRAP.
Early in my career, I mistook certainty for competence. If I'd done the analysis and reached a conclusion, I held that conclusion as a kind of professional identity. Changing my position felt like
admitting error. So I'd hold on longer than the evidence warranted.
I've since learned to separate the two. Conviction — grounded in reasoning and updated by evidence — is one of the most valuable things an advisor can offer. Stubbornness — maintaining a position past the
point where evidence supports it — destroys value silently and slowly.
The discipline I've built is this: whenever I hold a strong view, I force myself to articulate the two or three things that would change my mind. If I can't name them, I'm not being rigorous — I'm being
defensive.
THE FAILURES THAT HURT MOST WERE THE PEOPLE ONES
I can look back at every significant setback in my career and trace it, if I'm honest, to a people decision. A wrong hire that stayed too long. A partnership pursued for strategic logic while ignoring cultural misalignment. A founder who said the right things in every meeting but had a different operating philosophy the moment pressure arrived.
I've become a significantly better reader of people over 25 years. But more importantly, I've become more honest about the limits of that skill.
FAILURE AT SCALE IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN FAILURE AT SEED
Companies that test small and learn fast — that treat early market entry or product launches as experiments, not commitments — suffer smaller failures that produce outsized learning. I've advised
companies that spent million to learn something a $10,000 pilot would have revealed.
The best risk management isn't diversification or hedging. It's building a culture that surfaces bad news early, takes it seriously, and responds before small problems become expensive ones.
THE STORIES WE TELL OURSELVES
The most dangerous failure mode I've observed — in clients and, frankly, in myself — is the narrative failure. We build explanatory stories around outcomes to make them feel manageable, and those
stories protect our self-concept at the cost of accurate learning.
I've made it a practice, after every significant outcome — good or bad — to write a brief retrospective that specifically names what I'd do differently. Not what went wrong externally, but what I would change about my own judgment and decisions.
WHAT THIS ADDS UP TO
I'm a better advisor at 25 years than I was at five or ten — not primarily because I know more, but because I've failed more thoughtfully. Failure isn't the opposite of good judgment. It's the raw material.
Twenty-five years into this work, I've stopped being embarrassed about that. Failure — properly examined — is the most reliable source of durable wisdom I've found in business.
CONVICTION IS A TOOL. STUBBORNNESS IS A TRAP.
Early in my career, I mistook certainty for competence. If I'd done the analysis and reached a conclusion, I held that conclusion as a kind of professional identity. Changing my position felt like
admitting error. So I'd hold on longer than the evidence warranted.
I've since learned to separate the two. Conviction — grounded in reasoning and updated by evidence — is one of the most valuable things an advisor can offer. Stubbornness — maintaining a position past the
point where evidence supports it — destroys value silently and slowly.
The discipline I've built is this: whenever I hold a strong view, I force myself to articulate the two or three things that would change my mind. If I can't name them, I'm not being rigorous — I'm being
defensive.
THE FAILURES THAT HURT MOST WERE THE PEOPLE ONES
I can look back at every significant setback in my career and trace it, if I'm honest, to a people decision. A wrong hire that stayed too long. A partnership pursued for strategic logic while ignoring cultural misalignment. A founder who said the right things in every meeting but had a different operating philosophy the moment pressure arrived.
I've become a significantly better reader of people over 25 years. But more importantly, I've become more honest about the limits of that skill.
FAILURE AT SCALE IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN FAILURE AT SEED
Companies that test small and learn fast — that treat early market entry or product launches as experiments, not commitments — suffer smaller failures that produce outsized learning. I've advised
companies that spent million to learn something a $10,000 pilot would have revealed.
The best risk management isn't diversification or hedging. It's building a culture that surfaces bad news early, takes it seriously, and responds before small problems become expensive ones.
THE STORIES WE TELL OURSELVES
The most dangerous failure mode I've observed — in clients and, frankly, in myself — is the narrative failure. We build explanatory stories around outcomes to make them feel manageable, and those
stories protect our self-concept at the cost of accurate learning.
I've made it a practice, after every significant outcome — good or bad — to write a brief retrospective that specifically names what I'd do differently. Not what went wrong externally, but what I would change about my own judgment and decisions.
WHAT THIS ADDS UP TO
I'm a better advisor at 25 years than I was at five or ten — not primarily because I know more, but because I've failed more thoughtfully. Failure isn't the opposite of good judgment. It's the raw material.
About the Author: Scott Gelbard is the Founder of SGI Global Partners
Inc. and Managing Partner of Peak Ventures. With more than 25 years of
experience advising businesses across North America, Europe, and Asia.
.png)
Comments
Post a Comment